The 1881 life and times of Peter Broderick of Athenry

Extracts from the 1881/82 diary of Peter Broderick published in the Connacht Tribune in the 1990s. Writer John Flatley looks at the background of his arrest, Athenry’s reaction to it and spending Christmas in Galway Jail (now the site of Galway Cathedral).

One of the unsung heroes of the Land League’s campaign of passiveness getting underway in 1880 was Peter Broderick of Ivymount House, Athenry. A farmer and merchant and elected member of the Loughrea Board of Guardians, Peter’s career was put out-of-joint on his being lodged in Galway Jail on suspicion of promoting boycotting in 1881.

In a meticulously kept account of each day from November to March, he recorded the rigours of his arrest and incarceration; his dealings with prison staff, fellow prisoners and visitors, his thoughts on the developing political situation, and details about the gaol. His diary is a revelation of the deprivations of body and mind in prison; the effects of news about life outside on prisoners; the concern shown by newspapers, politicians and friends and a relatively humane regime at Galway Jail. The cursive handwriting and cogent sentences made for very pleasant reading.

Peter Broderick and his wile Julia ran the post office and shop in Athenry. One son, James, joined the Jesuits and based at Farm Street, London, published several books. The other son, Martin, became a professor at Nottingham University. The daughter, Mother Finbarr of the Sisters of Charity and Jesus and Mary, founded many convents in Ireland. Peter’s brother, John, was father of Sean Broderick, Fine Gael T.D., and Chris Broderick, MPSI, Athenry.

In the popular song ‘The Fields of Athenry’ there’s a line ‘Now a prison ship lies waiting in the bay, meaning Galway Bay, the depressing sentence for non-compliance with the handling of Ireland’s political economy in 1845. Thirty-five years later nothing had changed except that the prison was in Galway town.

Charles Trevelyan was unimpressed by the fact that one-third of the population those about to be hardest hit by the famine- could hardly afford bread at any price, nevertheless, this permanent Head of the Treasury, the top civil servant, had dictatorial powers of life and death. He was the guardian of the principles the State could not give people food.

W.E. Forster, appointed Chief Secretary for Ireland in 1880, displayed a similar unshakeable conviction that the enforcement of law would solve the agrarian problem in Ireland. Forster was not to duly concerned that laws weak in themselves require large bodies of men to enforce them. His main concern was that non- acceptance of the law had to be confronted with forces large enough to over-awe any attempt at violence.

William Forster was dominated by a sense of personal responsibility to solve the disorder prevalent in Ireland in the 1880s. To satisfy his conscience he had to keep the country quiet. The worst harm for Ireland (in contrast to the “disease of famine, political annihilation and ever recurring disputes about land”, Peter P. Broderick, Athenry 1881) was that the people should disobey or ignore the law or its agents.

Chief Secretary Forster was digging an even deeper hole for British rule in Ireland than he imagined. His use of over- awing force to counteract legitimate opposition to his agents- the landlords was to swell the ranks of the disaffected at Galway Gaol.

The people of Ireland, it appeared to him at that time, were not to be given the opportunity of showing their fitness for equality before the law. He could not bring himself to trust in the loyalty and good sense of the Irish people.

Passive disloyalty to his agents, though neither an open resistance to faw nor part of the repertoire of crime in the general disorder of the time, had to be eradicated by the use of the law.

In 1881 the British Government passed an Act ‘For the Better Protection of Person and Property in Ireland’. It became an offence to be suspected of incitement to boycotting.

Could that effectively remedy the unsettled condition of the land question in Ireland? Would a stretch in jail alter the sentiments and convictions of people advancing the cause of tenant farmers? Secretary Forster was naive.

In Athenry at the time there was a man who believed the injustices would not succeed.

Peter Broderick, a shopkeeper and farmer, kept a diary. He wrote:

“This year dawned upon our country with the hope that the next session of Parliament would devise means to alleviate the distress then prevailing. Men deep in knowledge and full of economic science asked in amazement how it was that one bad harvest could almost annihilate a nation and deeply and sadly the vison came before their minds that the disease above arose from the unsettled condition of the Land Question in Ireland.”

Broderick recognised the futility of waiting for Secretary Forster to satisfactorily deal with the Irish question. He wrote:

“Mid all the chaos and uncertainty then existing, a man who had played an humble part in a previous movement for his country appeared, and like a voice on the hilltop, like a beacon on a stormy ocean gave the people hope, bade them lift their drooping spirits-that their emancipation was in their own hands, and like he proverbial man clinging to the straw, the voice of this prophet of a new doctrine, Michael Davitt was heard and from end to end of the land of Ireland was raised the сту—’The Land for the people who till it’.

Peter Broderick was himself an appointed Secretary, Secretary of the Athenry Branch of the Land League which had been set up on St. Brigid’s Day. 1880. The means to be employed by the Branch were to be “strictly legal, honest and in accordance with the principles of justice, equity and morality”.

The weekly meetings were on Sundays, at 1 o’clock. Monthly meetings for the heads of circles were at 2 p.m. on the first Sunday of the month.

The Athenry Branch of the Land League consisted of the following offices:

President, The Very Rev. P. J, Canon O’Brien P.P. Athenry:

Vice- President, The Rev. P. J. MacPhilbin C.C. Athenry;

Secretary, Peter Broderick Esq.. Athenry;

Treasurer, Patrick Mahon Esq., Athenry.

Members of Branch Council:

Thomas R. Kelly, Athenry:

James Cloonan, Athenry,

Patrick: C. Kelly, Athenry,

John Lynskey, Athenry.

Heads of Circles:

John Melia. Montpelier,

John Shaughnessy. Cussaun;

Philip Fahy, Carnmore

Thomas Coyne, Park;

B. Scanlon, Newcastle;

Pat Ruane, Cudoo,

Pat Kelly. Castlelambert:

Andrew Keary, Clorane;

M. Fahy, Moyvilla

T. Callanan, Blain,

Luke Regan, Lodge;

P. Callanan, Kingsland:

John Malloy, Ballygurrane

John Kennedy, Lecarrue:

John Kindregan, Cahertubber;

Francis Burke, Cloonkeen;

Thomas Hanily. Woodvillage;

Pat Keamey, Turloughmore

Martin Kearney, Turloughmore,

John Morris, Turloughmore,

John Joyce, Greyforth,

Pat Shaughnessy, Mira;

Denis Forde, Lisheenavalle:

Francis Hanly, Grange;

M. Moran, Turloughmore;

Owen Connell, Claregalway;

Walter J. Hughes, Claregaiway;

Thomas Casserly, Claregalway:

Michael Murphy. Claregalway;

Stephen Luane, Cahermore;

Patrick Waishe, Lidecan

James Multy, Lidecan.

On Wednesday, November 9, 1881, at Athenry, Peter Broderick was arrested as a suspect. The warrant said he was ‘reasonably suspected’ of having, since the 30th day of September, 1880, been guilty of “inciting others wrongfully and without legal authority to intimidate diverse persons with a view to compel them to abstain from doing a certain act which they had a legal right to do, namely, to buy from and sell to and deal with certain persons...”

It was 5.10 p.m. that day when the inspector of Athenry, Mr. Bell, accompanied by a detective officer and two constables of the R.I. Constabulary, arrested Peter Broderick at his own door: “I presume you are Mr. Broderick. I have a warrant for your arrest.” He was given 45 minutes to prepare. Police were left in charge as he ate his dinner. (Broderick’s reports in his diary).

What about the rest of Athenry? How did they react to the arrest? These are the words of Peter Broderick.

“Literally, the town gathered to the house, and needless to say the dinner was abandoned. Durong the short time I had to stay I made the best arrangements I could for the future - my traps were all packed up and everything ready by the specified time.

“Then a scene of handshaking, kissing, crying and all the other etceteras of leave-taking almost unmanned me. Now in my lonely cell (he later recalled while in jail) when I look back on the scene, a feeling of gratitude must fill my breast for the deep marks of love and sympathy that night extended to me.

“As the time approached for my departure, immense crowds were assembled and immense forces too. The Constabulary, in large numbers and fully armed, were there—right, left and centre, they were there. Whether the motive was to inspire me with awe or the people, I am not in a position to say but I know if the movement was directed towards me it was a signal failure.

“I addressed a few parting words to assembled crowd, telling them to be of good cheer, that my treatment was, the variable course pursued by the authorities in power and requesting the people not to be led away into any acts of lawlessness on my account as I was fully prepared to suffer for the cause I advocated. My words appeared to have the desired efect.

“The hour was now at hand for my departure. Oh, that march to the railway station. What a memory! An immense cordon of armed Constabulary followed by an excited, cheering and yelling crowd and I the object of all. Were not the cause for which I suffered almost sacred I would blush at my position.”

At Athenry railway station there was unforeseen delay and after repeated leave-taking. the engine whistled. “The cheers were deafening and as the first move was made my exclamation of ‘God Save Ireland’ was re-echoed by a thousand voices,” wrote Peter Broderick.

On arrival at Galway terminus here was another surprise-a large crowd of cheering well-wishers. After a leave-taking with them, Peter Broderick was hurried away accompanied by a strong force of the Constabulary to Galway Gaol.

On November 19, 1881, the Board of Guardians of the Loughrea Union at its meeting unanimously passed this resolution: “That we desire to express our regret at the recent arbitrary arrest and imprisonment under the Coercion Act of a respected member of this Board - Mr. P. Broderick of Athenry, and that we tender to him in his prison call out wannest sympathy and the expression of our earnest hope for his speedy restoration to liberty, so that we may soon again have the pleasure of his presence amongst us at this Board of which since his election to it he has proved himself a useful, active and intelligent member.”

Early on the morning of Thursday, December 8, Peter Broderick “cast a thought to Old Athenry, whose inhabitants were then snugly ensconced in their virtuous beds”. On Sunday, 11th December he wrote: “This day fortnight is Xmas Day, a time of cheer throughout the world and we in all probability will be the inmates of a prison by that time.”

On Wednesday, 14th December, Peter Broderick had a visit from Frank Hennelly. who “had all the news from home. Was glad to hear of the collapse of Burton Persse’s pleasure fox-hunt. This taste of coercion might let him see the injustice to which others are subjected.”

On Friday, December 23. Peter Broderick notes: “the men are downcast at their position on the now approach to Xmas, not through any lack of courage but thinking of home and friends. There are many who think their imaginary crimes have now been sufficiently expiated for.”

Saturday, December 24, was the eve of the festival which Peter Broderick noted ‘unites mankind; the greatest of the great days of Christian love, rejoicing and festivity; the one that closes up the wounds caused by many differences; the one that at least in every house hold in Ireland cements more closely family ties, and the one which above all others brings back to the wanderer on a foreign strand happy thoughts of the loved ones at home.”

“I look around my dreary abode and ask myself where I am and can I imagine the festivities at home. The sad thought rises before my mind that! might as well be in far away Australia, or under the shadow of the Southern Cross or further still in pursuit of the Norh Pole, as be in the position which the exigencies of fate has placed me. I find myself entombed as it were in a living grave. We have Communion with the faithful but what more. We breathe circumscribed air. Our daily companions are men we have never known.

“Nevertheless, men who by their love of Ireland we have here. It is not of my friends or my acquaintances I complain (if this is the proper word), but of the source of the evil. Hell-born English Government

“As I looked at my abode, 13 x 6.5, this morning, these were the ideas that suggested themselves to me. When I got further into the day, when friends bade me goodbye and (oh, the irony!) a Merry Xmas. I thought again of my position. The day was in complete harmony with our status, as anything more miserable than the outlook it is hard to imagine.

“An incessant downpour until late in the day rather limited the area of our exercise and this part of the performance was consequently mostly executed in the hall. Often with a longing myself, O’Beinie and Tuite looked over the wall (to see the sky) that separated us from common humanity and indeed the mischievous idea once entered our minds of raising a mutiny. But then, the difficulties we met with, within and without, the obstacles to be overcome rose in such majestic power before our eyes that the idea was abandoned until next Xmas.

“But the machinations of the disloyalists was not yet satisfied. We should have our Christmas fare! That which was not allowed, illicit literature and illicit idstillation. To manage the necessary amount of those contraband articles the wits of all the conspirators were set to work. I take my divide of the laurels as my trophy was first to the front -”United Irishman, dated 24th Dec., 1881. One week after its suppression!

“Many and various were the enquiries how did I get it. No matter ‘tis here, was the reply. John unfolded a little parcel of innocent appearance and disclosed to the gaze of the bewildered —a further instalment of the illicit literature, a ‘Nation’ and a “Weekly News!”

But the big gun was not yet present and the absence of a drop of alcohol was being severely felt all around, “At this juncture Chief Warden Evans arrived, heavily freighted with his Xmas cargo. Greetings. Each man got his lot. My generous friends were Miss Rushe, Maria and Jots Broderick, Mrs. Mahon, Mrs. Carbry, Mgt. Whelen. This gave me an hours reading. Time was flying. I was visited by Thomas Higgins, M. Lardner and John L., Pat Kelly, by others.”

At Association the prisoners entertained themselves. “There was considerable fun. The Governor was present part of the time at the recitation. Mason or the Commissariat Officer arrived at this hour with supper and John S. brought the glad tidings of two bottles for ourselves if more came in the morning to divide it, If not to be conservative about supplies. When the order to cells arrived, all marched from Association to welcome the coming day. Supper was served round by Mr. Mason and indeed it was of a very indifferent character.

“Christmas wouldn’t be right without a drop of something. Peter ‘attacked number one bottle previously in my box. I boiled a saucepan of water over the gas jet, got sugar and all other essentials for a good tumbler and my efforts were quite successful. I could not but Feel amused even though the gloom and the solitude then around me as I indulged in the illegality of my acts. With ‘United Irishman’ in one hand and John Jameson’s best in the other I thought to drown grief.

Did the drink work wonders? No. “When the heart is full of home associations, full of memories of the past, I find it difficult with even the enticing stimulants in my possession to forget all - the memory of this night twelve months is fresh before me and when I consider the position I feel sad.”

From thoughts of home sprung a real and deeper loss: “my wants tended to be at my own fireside by the loving hand of a fond mother. When I miss her sweet face, who was ever beaning with love and smiles, her placid countenance is fresh before my mind as she lay is the sleep of death last summer. Her absence from the Circle of home is sad but I know she has gone to a better world.”

That heavy load on his heart - found consolation in the idea flashing across his mind of all the trials, all the bitterness and all the indignities, He whose birth we were on the eve of celebrating had to endure, I had to encounter for our sake.”

Pitiful thoughts of old times and all the old scenes of former days vividly arose before his mind as he eventually fell asleep, dozing placidly away when on the midnight air came the glad tidings that the anniversary of the Saviour was at hand. The joy birds were gladly proclaiming the blessed tidings and I fancied at that moment, when their brazen tongues were proclaiming “Peace on Earth to Men of Good Will”, how hard it was for me with the shadow of my prison bars on my ceiling and the general aspect of my abode.”

Peter was awake early on Christmas morning and felt glad the blessed day had dawned. At Mass at 8 p.m., read by Father Newell “who preached a rather poor sermon”. Breakfast consisted of “a dry loaf and a sausage” and he gave away to two fellow prisoners - J. Sweeney and P. Tully - portion of turkey received the previous evening.

Obviously, from the evidence of the hangovers on St. Stephen’s Day, Peter and his friends had indulged considerably in alcohol during Christmas Day. Some had ‘aching heads and sleepy eyed; others were ‘in a bad way and to all appearances no remedy at hand; another’ completely annihilated from an overdose of port.

On January 6, 1882, Twelfth Day, the last day of Christmas Peter Broderick mused that Christmas “will be perhaps the most remarkable one in my life …I hope that never again will it be spent under such circumstances - though if need be for the profession of my principle’s, ‘Justice for all”, the sacrifice is ever ready to be made unmindful of consequences.”

Arrival at Galway Prison

In the darkness that enveloped Galway Jail on the night of Wednesday, November 9. 1881, the gates of that “hospitable mansion’ were thrown open and Peter P. Broderick of Athenry was hurried inside as prisoner, a political suspect, suspected as principal of inciting to boycotting under the Act previously passed that year ‘For the Better Protection of Person and Property in Ireland’. Peter was shopkeeper and farmer.

He was hurried in the Governor’s Office where the Warden showed the warrant to the Governor, from the Governor back to the Constable and from the Constable to the Chief Warden. In the office the charge was road, entered in a “huge book’ and a receipt of Broderick’s delivery signed and given to the Constable.

In the office with two chief wardens - distinguished by the gold braid on their caps and the glittering crown on their coat collars - as well as a clerk. registered Peter Broderick’s age, complexion, colour of hair, eyes, appearance and all the “hue and cry evidences. His height was measured at five feet eight inches. He handed over his possessions, two one pound notes and a penknife. Chief Warden Number One searched for other possessions but found nothing else.

Then followed the lost act in the day’s drama, Peter Broderick being marched from the office to his cell, a trip that took him through the whole house. His first impressions? “The repeated banging of doors, clinking of keys and martial tread of office bearers”. The gas was burning in his cell the bed prepared and he was locked in.

Prison Cell

He looked around and measured the cell, sixteen feet long by five-and-a-half feet wide. the bed was placed on a kind of camp stool or folding bedstead. It comprised a straw mattress and a fibre mattress, two sheets marked in large letters “Galway Gaol”, two blankets and a quilt - all except the fibre mattress were prison property. The cell had a boarded floor, a groined ceiling and a semi-circular window about six feet above the floor. The radius of the window was about three-and-a-half feet, with the centre portion pivoting and in four panes. The outer portion was strongly guarded by ten vertical bars placed diagonally, loaded into tho stone and braced by three horizontal bars, all about two inches thick.

The furniture consisted of a plain deal table about twenty one inches by eighteen inches; an oak chair, a little mirror hung on the wall; a washing and a stop basin. In bold relief above the table was a copy of The Rules made by the Lord Lieutenant under the provisions of the Act for the Better Protection of Person and Property in Ireland, It comprised eighteen rules for the guidance of the prisoner, beginning with his admission and finishing with punishments. A bell pull and gas jet completed the internal furnishings.

The cell door was two inches thick, lined on the inside with sheet iron. Near the top of the door was a spy hole with a lid, affording the opportunity to observe the prisoner. Every half-hour the heavy shoes of the warden could be heard as he marched along he corridor, incessantly chinking keys, banging doors and calling our “All is well”. The noise and hard bed combined to keep sleep at bay for the prisoner on his first night.

Routine

In the morning darkness of Thursday, November 9. while the prison bells were ringing. the call door was opened and the gas was put on. About twenty minutes were allowed for getting ready for the day and then ‘in stentorian tones’ during the second unlocking of the door, the warden’s voice commanded “All Out”. Out meant the exercise yard.

Peter Broderick got a warm reception from the other prisoners. Their comments were consoling: “You here too. Good God, isn’t this too bad”, “Bad luck to them that sent you here”. O’Beine of Ballinamore went and ‘found something to cheer you up’ and Peter Broderick was in better fettle. A few minutes before eight o’clock the warden commanded “All In” and in they filed back to the cells.

Breakfast, consisting of two hard eggs, a cup of tea and a penny loaf, was then served in the cell. Writing paper was served around after breakfast. After the letter-writing time, the cell door was unlocked and ‘All Out repeated.

Time outside the cell lasted for two hours - one in the exercise yard, the other the Association Rooms where the prisoners met. Back to the ceils again, ten past twelve to ten past two. Dinner served there included a bottle of stout. Outside again to the exercise yard, ten past two to ten past four. Back indoors to the Association Rooms, ten past four to ten past five. Back to the cells, ten past five to half-past seven next morning.

Supper, consisting of a cup of tea, jenny loaf and one ounce of butter, was served around to the cells at half past five, the cell door was opened, tea utensils were removed and cell locked again. The Chief Warden went on his rounds and looking through the cell door aperative calling out “All’s Well”. The lights were put out at half-past eight. At half-past ten, the ceil door was opened and the Chief Warden holding a bulls eye lamp enters. He satisfies himself of the prisoner’s presence, calls out ‘All’s Well’ and passes off. Cell relocked.

The number of suspects imprisoned at Galway Jail ranged from time to time between forty and seventy. Some prisoners were transferred to Carrick-on-Shannon, Limerick or Armagh. The suspects at Galway Jail occupied the back seats of the gallery in the chapel on Sunday’s while the lower scats were occupied by convicted and untried prisoners. The female prisoners were on the ground floor - under the gallery - out of view of the males. Prisoners marched back to the cells after Mass on Sundays.

Exercise

There were two areas of exercise in the yard, and daily exercise began around 7.30 a.m. immediately after rising, often in the darkness before the winter dawn and often in the early morning moonlight. If there was severely cold air, as on December 12, 42 degrees plus fog, “the efforts to keep up blood circulation were laughable”. It was so cold on occasions it demanded violent exercises to keep warm. “The fierce marching of muffled men in the little circumscribed space’.” On very wet days the exercise areas were sloppy and disagreeable necessitating the use of a corridor for exercises.

The playing of ball went on all the time in the exercise areas. The Governor might on occasion visit the exercise yard laden with official papers. Prisoners could be informed of transfer, release, or court appearances while in the yard.

Prisoners on two occasions during Peter Broderick’s sojourn there brought up with the authorities the need to sheet the sides of a shed in the yard. Overcoats could be worn there on wet days. There was general amusement one Sunday morning when a prisoner appeared in the exercise yard sporting a top hat.

Stock-in-trade

Within a few days of arrival at Galway Jail Peter Broderick received from home consignment of personal items indicating social expectations of the time: two pairs of cuffs, six collars, four collar studs, razor, strap, tooth brush, soap, one handkerchief, Holy Water, beads, one pillow, two pillow cases, blankets, sheets, counterpane quilt and table cover.

A week later he made an inventory of stock-in-hand in his cell: one bed, two sheets, two pairs of blankets, two pullovers (one League), two pillow covers, one table cloth, one counterpane, one rug, one Ulster, one duster, one dress coat, one everyday coat, three pairs of trousers, two vests, three shirts, ten collars, three pairs of cuffs, two towels, four pairs of stockings, two pairs of drawers, two flannel shirts, two ties, four handkerchiefs, one night shirt, hair-brush, tooth brush, rack beads and prayer book. Monday’s items were sent to the prison laundry and were returned later in the week.

Isolation from the world outside, from the everyday bustle of life in Galway was almost total. An old factory whistle and the Angelus Bell ringing at 6 am. awakened the prisoners. Church bells pealing in early and mid-morning gave Peter Broderick the distinct impression there was rivalry between the churches in the town. “There appears to be a rivalry between the different church in towns. The Protestant church is tolling a very sweet peal, the Catholic churches also, all seeming to mock us in our lonely cages.”

Galway Band

On one occasion, Sunday, January 22, 1882, he “heard the Galway Band in the distance today, but no attempt was made to approach our quarters, as it would probably be an infringement on the loyalty of the serfs.”

Stamps for letters to be posted were paid for by the prisoners and there were daily deliveries of letters and parcels. Telegrams were sent from the prison, and others received. Messages left it the gate were delivered.

Newspapers taken by prisoners included “Freeman’s Journal, “Daily Express’. “Tuam News’, ‘Galway Observer”. Newspapers such as ‘Midland Tribune and ‘Cork Herald” were sent to prisoners by people outside. The Toronto Globe’ correspondent visited. Prisoners wrote articles for publication in newspapers. mostly in relation to conditions within the prison. Sometimes there was tension among prisoners when, for whatever reason, the matter published offended fellow prisoners.

Murmurings within the prison in relation to the daily diet led to letters being seat to Charles Stuart Parnell, M.P. On December 23, Mr. Duigenan of the Democratic Club, Walsall, arrived on the instructions of Mr. Chamberlain, M.P., the Government member, and “got the special privilege of seeing the suspects exercise”. That same evening a great row was raised on the arrival of the newspapers by the ‘Daily Express” report - ‘all but a few were accused of a wilful waste of Land League Funds.

Diet

The wardens were humane and, on occasion, could be courteous. On December 6 the Warden visited Peter Broderick at breakfast wanting to know what he would have for breakfast the following day (prison fare). It was a choice limited to stir-about and coffee: for one week. At supper the Warden asked about his preference for the coming week, tea or cocoa. In both cases he opted for the first alternative.

Following morning Peter Broderick returned from exercise (in the dark) to find ‘a bright culinary utensil of gigantic proportions was laid on the table. The weapon for onslaught on the stir-about - a big iron spoon - a pan filled almost to the top with stir-about and a saucepan of milk was the inviting repast for a cold morning. As I attacked my skilly, I really began to feel a foretaste of prison life. The stir-abour was pretty fair but abounded with salt.

He didn’t like it and ‘turned to the Anglo-Saxon cocoa with a bit of bread and butter (got in on the previous day)’. He observed in the refuse collected that “almost as much made its way back to the cookhouse as came from it.”

For dinner that day there were two big pieces of coarse broad and wretchedly strong and a pint of coffee, as strong and black as tar. Porter was not supplied today’. The evening meal of tea and brown bread was in his opinion ‘equally as good in every way as that supplied from outside. He was hopeful: “All in all, the fare was not so bad as an outside world believes it to be. I expect (D.V.) to be able to rough it.”

John Dillon, M.P. wrote to a fellow prisoner. Mr. Harris, “regretting anything should occur to annoy the men in Galway prison and saying the prison diet would be only for a few weeks” - the men considered this term quite long enough.

The following day, Thursday, December 8, was a meat day on prison fare and “was altogether fair. The quantity was very nearly sufficient and the quality good - four potatoes, three-quarters pint soup (good) and about eight or nine ounces of boiled beef. No porter supplied”. The breakfast earlier in the day had been poor.

By mid-December Peter Broderick was arranging for breakfast to be served from outside. Others did the same. By the end of the month dinner and supper were being reserved by him from outside. The outside supplier was Mrs. Mason.

Visitors came virtually daily and the prisoner had the choice of seeing them or not. They were welcome in nearly all instances, thought Peter Broderick refused to see a certain gentleman for quite a while. On February 7, 1882, he was visited by two men and ‘felt very indifferent towards their attention’.

Fasting

On February 13 a woman from Kilconnell visited giving Peter Broderick ‘the usual sanctimonious consolation’. On Monday, February 20, he read in the Galway Observer” that he was “careworn and thin from the confinement”. The following Sunday, Feburary 27 at Mass in Galway Jail, Father Creaven the celebrant commented strongly on the necessity of fasting.

Unpleasant Life in Galway Jail

By the 1880s the warders in the jails of Ireland were Home Rulers. By 1886, five years after the Athenry Land Leaguer, Peter Broderick, was interned at Galway Jail, the easy-going Governor of Galway Jail, Captain Mason, who had relaxed the rules, was obliged to leave the prison service.

The General Prisons Board, through the reports of its inspector Pierce Joyce was made aware of the relaxation of rules at Galway Prison. Joyce made regular visits during Broderick’s time there. Others to fall victim of the officious comments of Joyce were a Chief Warder, Mr. Grant, who was degraded, reduced in pay and transferred to a convict prison, A Warder was dismissed and Professor Kincaid, the Medical Officer, was ticked off.

On arrival at Galway Jail, on Wednesday, November 9, Peter Broderick was “hurried to the Governor’s office. The warrant was shown by the Warder to the Governor, sent from the Governor back to the Constable and by the Constable to the Chief Warder in the office. The charge was read, entered in a huge book and a receipt for my delivery signed and given to the Constable” - a man named Reilly.

It was all very serious business in the office: two Chief Warders (distinguished by the gold braid on their caps and the glittering crown on their coat collars) and a clerk logging the details, name, ago, complexion, colour of hair, eyes, appearance, height. Peter Broderick on being asked had he anything in his possession, handed over two one pound notes and a penknife and then: “Chief Warder No. 1 excused himself for doubting my words and made a formal search, resulting in what I had told him.*

The prisoner asked for “a good cell and they said they would do their best.

Broderick’s account of his imprisonment is to be discovered in his daily diary begun on November 9. “Thoughts in Prison. An excerpt from a local paper of that time (probably The Galway Vindicator’) described the arrest of Peter Broderick P.L.G. and P. C. Kelly Esq. of Athenry, both gentlemen, well-known and highly respected, as “arbitrary”. Both were removed to jail at different times and different ways. The excerpt explained: “As advocates of the temperance cause and the great cause of land reform, they were widely known and it is a well-known fact that tenant farmers for miles around Athenry always looked on them as their best friends and soughs their advice whenever it was needed. Their arrest is the most arbitrary as their acts were always public and regular reports of the meetings where they acted as secretaries appeared in the press. However, such an outrage on such men, as well as many others, is looked upon as springing from the latest development of the resources of civilisation.

As Peter Broderick appeared in the exercise yard early on his first morning “all hands approached with their congratulations .... Pat Kelly.. . John Sweeney ... Glennon... Conneely with a downcast look says may bad luck to them that sent you here, Madden, I suppose”. Conneely’s intuition was confirmed the following Monday, Nov. 14th, when Broderick’s Athenry visitors revealed to him that “Madden was under police protection”.

Notwithstanding the walls of the prison there was transparency about what went on there. Reports on individual prisoners and on matters such as prison diet appeared regularly in the newspapers. Influential public representatives like Charles Stuart Parnell, Burton Persse, John Redmond and John Dillon, would lobby... at Westminster on behalf of the prisoners. Questions asked in parliament were answered with Civil Service completeness and Westminster put their trust in Inspector Joyce’s reports. Mr. Chamberlain MP of the Government sent his own representative to observe conditions in Galway Jail on one occasion.

A combination of sensitivity to the Home Rule cause and a pragmatic strategy to keep the prisoners from bringing to the attention of newspapers any inhumane treatment bred a certain leniency. Within a week Peter Broderick was being asked by the Prison Governor if he wanted anything special. Knowing Broderick liked to read and write the Governor allowed him to leave on the gas till 10 p.m. (an hour and a half extra). He also supplied a candle in case Broderick didn’t like the gas. This discretion permitted him to write and read until 10 p.m. when the Chief Warder was on his rounds outside cells, looked in through the aperture in Broderick’s door and called ‘All’s Well’ before moving on to the next cell.

Within another couple of weeks the Warder would be making enquiries about Broderick’s preference for breakfast, though it was the stark alternative of stir-about or coffee. The departing affable’ Governor got many God Speeds From the prisoners and the new Governor—in early December— was being described as “... a pleasing gentleman... rather attentive, he frequently parades the premises.” By early January Broderick could write in his dairy: “got a nagging from Mason, between self and Sweeney”

By February, when John Fahy visited Broderick he was in possession of ‘contraband’ (drink), as Broderick noted in his diary “but not able to pass Customs Officer Mason a supply”, Mason was not the only lenient one. Broderick noted a series of meetings of the prisoners Social Club on the first day of Spring “to say thanks to the kindness of Watson’. The previous day they had procured some contraband across the rails”. On another occasion (in December) during the visit of four Athenry friends, Father Peter McPhilbin, Lizzie Lardner, Mrs. Lardner and John Kelly, there was a “bit of legerdemain over the rails unknown to Flannery” (the Warder). That night he had a “glass of punch. heated water by the gas”.

The regulations regarding the length cf visits could also be stretched. Warder Mahony, on occasion, allowed extra time.

The number of prisoners varied from time to time, following new arrivals, releases or transfers to other prisons or to go to court for trail. A. Keary, ‘a respected farmer from Athenry arrived the day after Broderick, but by early December the Governor notified Keary to proceed by first train to the prison a Carrick-on-Shannon to await trial. Broderick described an occasion of new arrivals: “we take it as an indication of the further enforcing of the illimitable resources of civilisation”. Sometimes there were seventy to eighty prisoners in Galway Jail.

They came from many parts. Tuite from Mullingar; Fallon from Moneen; ‘Chief Justice” Nond from Roscommon; O’Connor from Castlerea; Malachy Cloonan, the jobber, from Loughrea; Thomas Plower from near Loughrea; Lyons from Ballyhaunis; Coughlan and Connor from Kiltulla; O’Beirne from Ballinamore; P. J. Hanley the political doctrine of passiveness, but no way did this now apply among themselves.

For instance, when the Ladies League announced they would be no longer accountable for catering, their response to this presumptuous dictation’ was swift. Broderick observed: “the men object to being ruled by the Kilmainham directorate and as their reason that they went three months on prison fare before and none others followed. General dissatisfaction is exhibited...”

Prison fare was not a preferred option but Broderick records for Monday, January 23, 1882: “Today 40 men went on prison fare for a week, the savings to be given to Old Fallon (of Moneen, Athenry) now undergoing fortnight’s imprisonment for holding his house and lands against the decree of Persse of Roxboro. A most meritorious act. The money will amount to close of £40 for one week”.

The men could be fractious as well, As Broderick noted of Roscommon man Nond and Harrington: “Tonight in Association Nond and Harrington showed their tempers over the dietary question and both gentlemen are possessed of tempers. Nond was very liberal in his invectives against headquarters”.

Another day there was a great row in the exercise yard: “Tom Cunningham was directly accused of the Correspondence to the Daily Express in which people were accused of wasting Land League funds. Harrington defended him. The Gibbons got wild, rushed at Cunningham. Hanly from Roscommon was also on the onslaught on him. Cunningham declared his accusers liars’ and showed a contradiction he had written of the matter. Harriss interfered. The Warders ran to and fro and in the midst of the confusion Cunningham disappeared. Feeling was running very high.. it was miraculous why there was not a general melee. Cunningham did not appear subsequently during the day”.

There was, on another occasion in the yard, a right to-do about the 15 shillings per week Kilmainham proposal, ‘dictation from Kilmainham’. Nond and the Roscommon men wanted three meals a day or nothing, while Harrington and the Galway men were loud in their denunciation of Nond’s references to Parnell and Dillon. The notion of dictation wound up Noad and soon the word suggestion was replaced by dictation, 15 shillings a week plus one meal per day. At issue was the suggestion from Kimainham that each of the prisoners receive (from the Land League’s prisoners fund) the sum of fifteen shillings per week and be provided also with one meal per day courtesy of the Ladies League.

It was resolved that the issue be settled during Association hour. Nond’s men maintained that giving prisoners fifteen shillings per week set a premium on crime because labouring men who were presently only on receipt of six shillings a week would be tempted to commit outrages to go to prison and receive fifteen shillings a week. Harriss and Glennon for the Galway men, moved an amendment to the proposal of Mr. Dillon “that unless three meals a day as heretofore were given we would not accept the Kimainham terms”. The Amendment was carried in a vote by a majority of fourteen. The fifteen shillings men were defeated.

One can see that the presence of the warders was more benign then officious. Warder Wilkinson was in the observation box in the visiting quarters one day when John Fahy and Willie Higgins visited: a little legerdemain behind his back and very nicely manipulated’. That evening Broderick and Sweeney had an agreeable evening with the contraband., Warder Flannery was ‘quite mystified” by their good humour. Another day Mrs. Carberry manipulated half a pint behind the eagle eye of Chief Warder O’Keeffe’ and later on Broderick accorded ‘ample justice to it with help from three friends. Of course, Broderick’s generosity was reciprocated another day.

Broderick perceived the irony of the availability of such contraband as cargo from Jamaica’, an abundance of stout of Jameson, in a place designed for deprivation. He noted that did Chief Secretary for Ireland, William E. Forster “know how endurable he has made prison life to some of us, bewilderment would seize him”. Broderick sometimes fancied he was at home ‘until the black iron door, the green ceiling and W. E. Forster’s Proclamation remind me where I am’.

Little information is given about Warder Gildea but an incident involving Broderick and Gildea gives an insight into the civility of the prison staff. In March, 1882, Peter Broderick had a row with Warder Gildea following ‘an act of impertinence’ by Gildea, Broderick reported the matter to the Governor, and only the latter’s announcement of an investigation into the matter on the following day in the office staved off a proper rumpus among Broderick’s neighbouring inmates. At the investigation “Gildea proved himself a bare ruffian and was severely reprimanded by the Governor for his insolence”.

Outside, the Unionist landlord class saw where boycotting was leading. Burton Persse made a request to the Lord Lieutenant for the release of the prisoners. His effort, “neither requested nor desired by us,” had tittle effect, and Broderick was glad to hear from visitors in December of the collapse of Burton Persse’s pleasure foxhunt”. Broderick opined: “This taste of coercion might let him see the injustice to which others are subjected”.

There was to be no amelioration of the odium of Land Leagers for overaweing representing force by the police and army and the events in Athenry in late January increased tension within the jail. Broderick’s brother John was arrested but the vivid accounts received devastated all the prisoners.

Peter Broderick wrote of Athenry’s sad tale of January 27: “The authorities made a great display of powers. Military and Constabulary concentrating from all points and never in the recent history of Athenry was such a day witnessed. A general search was made for arms and scarcely a house in town did not receive a ‘Royal’ visit. Of course, nothing discovered. Father McPhilbin suffered the greatest indignity as in his absence his room and contents were thoroughly and disgustingly ransacked. Not even ‘The Lord of Hosts’ was spared as the Tabernacle in which He resided vile hands pulled down”.

During the onslaught on the town a visitor from Chicago Miss O’Shaughnessy, happened to be in Lardners’ house. She too, was subjected to a search. Father P. J. McPhilbin was down visiting his mother at Castlebar at the time. On hearing of the attack he wrote a letter, published in The Tuam News, informing the authorities publicly he would be back io Athenry the following Saturday by the half-past four train. They could arrest him then if they wished.

“If I am arrested for words spoken coolly, deliberately, without betraying any symptoms of passion from the altar and after Mass, the priests at the Catholic Church in Ireland will require to submit for the future their instructions to their flocks to the supervision of Messrs. Foster and Blake”, he wrote.

The Athenry curate declared he had denounced the commission of outrages frequently before. He wrote: “Athenry parish had been more than ordinarily free even from agrarian outrages and in cautioning the people I also spoke of the outrages committed on myself and on the Blessed Sacrament as also on the houses of innocent country people without the authority of a warrant”.

On the same day as Father McPhilbin’s letter was published, Pater Broderick, for years a public representative, wrote a letter to the Clerk of the Loughrea Union, Mr. Egan, in relation to the proceedings of the Loughrea Board of Guardians in connection with Athenry Sewerage. He had been re-elected to the Board and took exception to the compromise being proposed. “The: proposition is most commendable if it entails the further expense on already overtaxed rate payers, I beg to protest against the adoption of any such course. In my mind, the Board of Guardians in forming a Committee for the purpose specified are so far exceeding their duties... You are already aware, I presume, that a contract exists for keeping in repair and free from nuisance the streets of Athenry and if this is nor performed in the spirit the agreement by the contractor there remains another medium of redress”.

Broderick’s ability in advocating propositions was recognised within Galway Jail and he was appointed to a Committee to represent the general wants of the prisoners. After ten weeks in the jail he had a chat with the Governor about the desirability of applying to W. E. Forster for a parole “in order to look after business matters’. but the Governor strongly advised against the prudence of it.

Hopes of release were raised by the attitude of the Irish Parliamentary Party at Westminster and by its tactic of obstruction. Conditional releases were offered to some prisoners, but as a group the prisoners counselled against accepting the conditions attached. An amnesty at Christmas would not be accepted if it was “fraught with any danger to their political purity.” They resolved to remain imprisoned “until it is free and unfettered, to abide by our fate.”

Peter Broderick was an insatiable reader and an inveterate letter writer, corresponding every seven or so days. His reading while in prison included a biography of Henry Grattan, Knocknagow, Corbett’s Advice to Young Men, The Imitation of Christ, and the works of Thomas Davis.

Broderick accepted his fate. Excluded from the outer world like a criminal, he reminded himself that he was imprisoned only “on the suspicion of some enemy with an imaginary treasured wrong… for advocating in my humble way the wants of our motherland I have offended against the mighty.” He found a striking similarity between Matt Donovan, the imprisoned hero of Knocknagow held in a Clonmel cell, and his own situation in Galway Jail.

Broderick saw the harmful effects of imprisoning people on suspicion of imaginary crimes. He regularly reflected: “What benefit to society has been my arrest and imprisonment?”

He understood that British supremacy in Ireland could not compel the kind of obedience to its laws that is the natural outcome of loyalty. For

Broderick one only needed to look around and daily see the outrages, the glaring injustices enacted on the people of Ireland in the name of law, and he was himself imprisoned “for not even the semblance of a crime”.

But the prisoners sang and whistled. On one evening in the Association Rooms P. C. Kelly sang “The Rising of the Moon’; M. Spelman sang ‘Our Land Shail Be Free; Conneely sang “The Fenian Man-of-War”; Harrington recited “The Pall of Poland’; John Sweeney sang The Vagrants of Erin” and ‘Lord Dunsandle’, and Hooban had them all in stitches with tall tales. Without warning the stentorian tones of the Warder’s “All Our” dispersed the gathering and ‘the dissolute ruffians’ marched off to their cells.

Entries in Peter Broderick’s diary abruptly end on March 15, 1882. They contain verses and thought provoking extracts from books he had read. He also wrote there an imaginative dream-like story about an imaginary Christmas Day amongst the suspects in Galway Jail.

We’ll give the last words to two of his friends, Tuite and O’Beirne. Tuite on February 19th (the Sunday before Lent) announced he “refuses to drink any more contraband as he wants to keep steady before his release (!) while he expects every day, O’Beirne is in the same category”.